Training for Long-Term Results
🎰 Why Dog Training Works Like a Slot Machine (and Why Quitting Rewards Breaks Behavior)
One of the most common mistakes I see in dog training is this:
People start out rewarding their dog for everything — every sit, every down, every good choice — and then one day they just stop.
No treats. No praise. No payoff.
And then they’re surprised when the behavior disappears.
Here’s the reality: you can’t go from rewarding your dog for every correct response to rewarding them never and expect the behavior to stick long-term.
Dogs don’t work that way.
Think of Training Like a Casino Slot Machine
If a slot machine paid out every single time you pulled the lever, it wouldn’t be exciting — and it wouldn’t keep anyone playing.
If it never paid out, people would walk away.
What keeps people glued to slot machines is the random payout. You never know which pull will be the winner… but you know one is coming.
That exact same principle applies to dog training.
Early Training = Frequent Payouts
When your dog is first learning a behavior, the “lever” is easy to pull.
Sit? đź’° Reward.
Look at you? đź’° Reward.
Calm moment? đź’° Reward.
At this stage, your dog is learning how the game works. Frequent rewards build understanding and confidence.
Long-Term Training = Random Payouts
Once your dog understands the behavior, the mistake people make is either:
• Paying every single time forever, or
• Cutting rewards out completely
Neither creates reliable behavior.
Instead, you meter rewards off gradually.
Now the dog never knows which sit, recall, or heel is going to hit the jackpot:
• Sometimes it’s food
• Sometimes praise
• Sometimes play
• Sometimes nothing
But the possibility of a reward keeps them engaged.
Why Random Rewards Create Reliable Dogs
A behavior that might pay off is a behavior your dog will keep offering.
A behavior that never pays off eventually disappears.
Random reinforcement creates:
âś” Motivation
âś” Persistence
âś” Reliability under distraction
This is how you get behaviors that last beyond the treat pouch.
Pay Well When It Matters
Even with random rewards, don’t go cheap in hard situations. New environments, big distractions, or difficult asks should still come with bigger payouts.
The casino doesn’t stop paying jackpots — it just doesn’t pay them every time.
Bottom Line
Great training isn’t about bribing your dog forever or quitting rewards cold turkey.
It’s about teaching the game, then keeping it fun, fair, and unpredictable — just enough to keep your dog pulling the lever
Set up a remote coaching session and I can help you with understanding concepts like this along with solving many problem behaviors right from home.
Remote Coaching Available Nationwide
Because smart training beats frustration every time.
